careerbydoing
← High-energy theory

High-energy theory

How much symmetry a theory is allowed to have

About 15 min if you have seen this material before, 45 min or so if it is new to you.

Background
A symmetry of a theory is an operation that turns one of its particles into another and leaves the physics unchanged. Symmetries are worth a great deal, because they relate things that would otherwise have to be measured separately: if an operation turns particle A into particle B, then whatever is true of A is forced to be true of B. A theory with enough symmetry has its entire particle content fixed by the symmetry alone. Every particle carries a number called its A massless particle's spin measured along its direction of motion, taking whole-number or half-integer values of either sign., which is its spin measured along its direction of motion. It comes in steps of a half: the photon carries 11, the electron 12\tfrac12, the The massless particle of helicity 2 whose exchange produces gravity. 22. Nothing below depends on what helicity means physically. What matters is that it is a number attached to each particle, and that the operations move it. A symmetry whose operations change helicity by half a unit, turning bosons into fermions and back. is a set of such operations, each of which shifts helicity by half a unit, and a theory is labelled by how many it has. That number is written NN.
A helicity is a whole number or a whole number plus a half, of either sign. Supersymmetry gives a theory some number NN of operations, and each of the NN raises the helicity of the particle it acts on by 12\tfrac12. In reaching any one particle no operation can be used twice, and applying two of them in either order gives the same particle. So start from the particle of lowest helicity and reach the others by applying operations. Which particle you arrive at is fixed by which operations you used, and different sets give different particles. Since none repeats and the order does not matter, that is a set chosen from the NN, and the particle's helicity is the lowest helicity plus half the number of operations in the set. The theory's content is the count of particles at each helicity. Take the theory to hold exactly one such collection; it is called a The set of particles that the supercharges map into one another, treated as a single object.. Here is the whole of that worked through for N=2N = 2, starting from a lowest helicity of −12-\tfrac12. Call the two operations 11 and 22:
  operations used     helicity      how many
  ---------------     --------      --------
  none                  -1/2            1
  {1}   or   {2}           0            2
  {1,2}                 +1/2            1
Four particles: one at −12-\tfrac12, two at 00, one at +12+\tfrac12. The counts 1 2 11\ 2\ 1 are the number of subsets of each size, and they add to 22=42^2 = 4. Particles of whole-number helicity are Particles of whole-number helicity are bosons; those of half-integer helicity are fermions., and those of half-integer helicity are fermions. So this theory holds two bosons and two fermions. Note the span. Every operation raises helicity by 12\tfrac12, so using all NN of them raises it by N/2N/2, and the top of the list therefore sits exactly N/2N/2 above the bottom. For N=2N = 2 that span is 11, which is the distance from −12-\tfrac12 to +12+\tfrac12. Two more rules apply. Flipping the sign of every helicity in the list has to give back the same list, counts included, which is why the N=2N=2 example was started at −12-\tfrac12 rather than anywhere else. And no consistent interacting theory contains a particle of helicity above +2+2 or below −2-2.
The parts below work out what such a theory contains, and how large NN is allowed to get.
(a)
Take N=4N = 4. Give the number of particles at each helicity, from lowest to highest, as whole numbers separated by spaces. The counts do not depend on which helicity the list starts from, so you do not need to work that out first.
(b)
Now leave NN free, and use the fact that no particle has helicity above +2+2 or below −2-2. What is the largest NN a theory can have?
(c)
In that largest theory, how many particles have helicity between −1-1 and +1+1? Include both ends, and the half-integer values in between.
(d)
In that same theory, count the bosons and count the fermions. Give the number of bosons.

Past 1.2 hr on this? That usually means a missing prerequisite rather than a lack of effort — worth reading up before pushing further, starting with Supersymmetry (Wikipedia).

Want to go deeper?